If the recording industry lowers its prices, it could capture some of these sales lost to piracy. Get off of my lawn! There are sites that you can go on that you can download songs and albums for a small fee. It's not gonna change my life any, but it sure bothers me that somebody is taking what they don't own, and it bothers me that somebody who's trying to succeed now and starting off doesn't have a chance in hell, more than likely, of ever getting that pot of gold.
Napster introduced a revolutionary new idea that was to forever change the way people thought about music: But will they be doing anything morally wrong? Few people think they were wrong just before they were legalised. As the Internet grows and the vast number of illegal downloads grows with it peoples jobs are shrinking.
Why is there such a disconnect? But things are not so clear when the relationship between gain and loss are more complex. As mentioned on the RIAA Recording Industry Association of Americathe penalties for breaching the copyright act differ slightly depending upon whether the infringing is for commercial or private financial gain.
Theft Law in the Information Agethe legal philosopher Stuart Green has pointed out that treating all infringement of property as theft subject to the same legal rubric is a relatively new development. Opposing views Two rival camps dominate public discussion around the ethics of illegal downloading.
When you see pictures, videos, and interviews of music artists they do not look or sound like they are struggling to get by. Theft is a criminal act and can lead to fines or jail time. Some feel that it is ok the take music from these famous artists but if it continues less and less music will be created, causing the high percentage of unemployment to only grow larger.
Protecting public goods On the other hand, the fundamentalist libertarian position is problematic because it treats all intellectual property infringement as a victimless crime.
In his fascinating book, 13 Ways to Steal a Bicycle: Most artists dream to make it big one day and be paid for the songs that they write and sing. The RIAA is just enforcing them. Butch [ID-1] If you forget this list, you can find most of their names here.
Most peer-to-peer users could never afford the fines and court fees associated with their violations. If an artist produces music that people enjoy, that artist should be compensated. First, I now have a copy of the CD. In downloading your film, I have not excluded you from its use, or your ability to benefit from it.
It does not matter what is being stolen or whom it is being stolen from. So is downloading illegal music ethical?Ethical issues is pertaining to or dealing with morals or the principles of morality; ethical is pertaining to right and wrong in conduct, involving or expressing moral approval, in accordance with principles of conduct that are considered correct, especially those of a given.
Is it immoral to download music illegally?
up vote 62 down vote favorite. Intellectual property issues in particular are at a very interesting point. On the one hand there are those who would claim that something like an idea, or a sound, or a style is something of value and should be guarded jealously and paid for dearly, while others.
Ethical Issues with Illegaly Downloading Music For years now people have found ways to take music off the Internet and put it onto their own computer, iPod, or blank CD. It all started in with the creation of Napster.
The Ethics of Music Sharing. By Dan on December 2, "Downloading MP3s drives up the cost of music for everybody else." There are also some issues with what percentage of your CD cost is going to pay lobbyists, though that's another topic.
There are also some significant benefits to having a robust and widely adopted file-sharing. If there are so many lawful issues surrounding the downloading of music, you might wonder why there is such an influx of MP3 players, CD burners, and even software that allows users to easily rip music from a CD to their computer.
The simple answer is that these devices do have a legitimate and legal fair use association. Illegal downloading of music has negative consequences for the music industry, including fewer artist royalties, loss of jobs and tighter budgets.Download